Sign up for our monthly newsletter and get your FREE copy of "5 GRANDMA BLUNDERS AND HOW TO AVOID THEM!"

7 Insights on Downsizing Through Generations

This essay by Marni Jameson first appeared in The Mercury News on August. 27, 2019.

Going through a parent’s belongings is a rite of passage almost none of us avoids. A task that seems straightforward on the surface can grab you by the ankles and drag you under with the uncompromising pull of a riptide.

At age 98, Deborah Robison’s mother decided to move from her one-bedroom apartment to a smaller place in a community that offers more senior support.

“The move was all her idea,” Deborah said. “Mom has always been forward looking and organized. And she loves the new place. The support makes her feel more secure.”

More parents like this, please.

“She’s just worried that clearing out her apartment will be too much trouble for me,” Deborah added, waving her hand as if swatting a minor nuisance.

The apartment, of course, tells a different story. The packed-up place is full of heavy old furniture, antiques, grandchildren’s artwork and more than two dozen needlepoint items — stools, chairs, pillows, wall hangings — made by Deborah’s grandmother. Colored Post-It notes dot the furniture and boxes like confetti.

“Each color indicates where the pieces are going,” said Deborah. The blue sticker items will be trucked to Pennsylvania, where they’ll be divided among family members according to her mother’s wishes.

On Monday, another truck will pick up everything else and make four drops: Mom’s new smaller place, Deborah’s house, the consignment store and finally the donation center.

“The stuff that gets off the truck last goes in first,” said Deborah. Overwhelming as these logistics are, I knew this was the easy part. She was starting to see that, too. “I had no idea how submerged I would get. I thought I was going to just pack and ship, but that was the least of the work. I am walking that line between preserving the family history, and not perpetuating the avalanche that compounds with each generation. I mean, I have three sets of china.”

Ever curious about how smart, thoughtful people navigate these waters, I asked Deborah about the highs, lows and findings of her downsizing journey.

Biggest shock: “How many keepsakes my mother had. She saved every birthday and Mother’s day card ever sent to her. That was overwhelming.”

Biggest burden: “When you inherit items that previous generations have placed great value in, it becomes instilled in you that these pieces have value (though they often don’t). You feel a responsibility to find a good home for the piece and balance that against the reality that you really don’t want to keep it in your house.”

Best resource: Online outlets, like Craigslist, offer more avenues to sell furniture today quickly without relying on consignment stores, which are pretty selective. “Selling a piece to someone who really wants or needs it gives you the satisfaction that you’ve done right by the piece and by your parent,” she said.

Best idea: Because she didn’t want to ship items to relatives and hand pieces down to her 26-year-old twin daughters without context, she gathered facts with her mom’s help, and typed notes to send along. Notes included details about the original owner, and when and why the item was used. For example, Deborah’s great-grandmother became a widow in the early 1900s. To support herself and her two young children, she opened a general store in Philadelphia. Customers used brass scoops to get items sold from barrels. Deborah now has one of the scoops.

“Until you know how she came to open the store and why, the scoop is pretty meaningless,” she said.

Best advice: Talk to family elders now while their stories are still alive. Deborah’s paternal grandmother needlepointed all those items to calm her nerves while both her sons, including Deborah’s dad, were fighting World War II. “Each family member will get a pillow, which some are more enthusiastic about than others,” she said. But an object means more when connected to a story, and a story means more when connected to an object.

Most unexpected finding: Family members differ on how much or little they want. Some want many items; others want few, she said, confirming what I’ve long preached: How much you want of someone’s possessions has no correlation to how much you loved them.

Biggest takeaway: Cull as you live rather than postpone the inevitable. “This has motivated me to pare my things down, starting with my crystal,” she said. “Once I get through mom’s stuff, my stuff is next.”


1 thought on “7 Insights on Downsizing Through Generations”

  1. Great post. Probably one of the hardest things to do. And yes, I have things from my great grandmother and on to the present generation. Not sure any of the kids are going to want that “stuff” (or have room for it.) But I’m not sure I’m the one capable emotionally of making those decisions without a lot of input.

Comments are closed.

Some Kudos We've Received

Scroll to Top